Skip to Main Content

PSYC 313: Opioids and the Opioid Crisis: Evaluating Sources

Evaluating Your Sources

As you gather sources for your annotated bibliography, it is important that you think critically about the types of references you use, as well as how and why they were created. Has the source been peer-reviewed by experts in the field, and if not, what other types of quality control are present? Is it an empirical research article, and how do you know?

 If you are ever unsure of whether a source is appropriate for your assignment, you are always welcome to reach out to a librarian for help! 

The Peer Review Process

Finding Peer Reviewed Articles

  • Look for the symbol above while searching in the library catalog
  • Search for the journal in the library catalog Journal Search to see if it is peer-reviewed
  • Find out more about the journal by going to it's home page. Try looking in the "About" or "Article Submission" sections to learn about if and when they use peer review in their editorial process.
  • You may also consider looking at the journal's editorial board webpage to learn more about the expertise and perspectives of the journal 

Grey Literature

For your literature review, you are required to cite at least 15 peer-reviewed empirical research articles. However, you may encounter and cite other kinds of scholarly literature, or gray literature, and it's important to understand what makes them different than traditional journal articles.

Put simply, grey literature is information produced outside of traditional publishing and distribution channels. This can include research produced by academic, government, or business sources. For example, a journal article is ultimately controlled and distributed by it's commercial publisher, but a dissertation or thesis is produced in an academic environment, and generally not published commercially outside the institution. Grey literature is usually not peer-reviewed, and processes of quality control can vary depending on the source type.

 

Adapted from the UNSW Sydney "Grey Literature" libguide and Simon Fraser University libguide on grey literature.

Empirical vs Review Articles

 

 

 

You have been tasked with finding at least 15 peer-reviewed empirical research articles for your annotated bibliography. 

What sets apart an empirical study from other types of scholarly work is the presence of original data collection driven by a research question, ultimately leading to a conclusion based on the data. Unlike a review article or a literature review that attempts to collect and synthesize salient literature on a particular topic, an empirical research article reports on the collection and analysis of original data in order to answer a research question.

Things to look for:

  • Original data collected by the authors presented in the "Results" section
  • Phrases like "In this study...", "We report...", "We manipulated...", "These findings show that...", "In present study..."
  • Methodology can be replicated 
  • Quantitative data is summarized in the abstract

 

Need help? Just ask!

 

 

Don't want to chat? See: Other ways to get help