Skip to Main Content

CHEM 348: Polymer Chemistry: Evaluating Sources

Source Evaluation: Your Responsibility

While resources found in databases like SciFinder go through an analytical vetting process unlike many sources found on the open web, it is still your responsibility to do research on each source you find. For example, if you are looking for peer-reviewed sources, not all source types in SciFinder will have gone through this specific editorial process (For example; patents and conference proceedings). This does not mean that these sources are necessarily unsuitable for citation in your work, but it is still important to understand how they were produced, reviewed, and came to be in SciFinder. Below find some tips and tricks to evaluating the credibility, accuracy, and authority of your sources.

The Peer Review Process

Lateral Reading

Lateral reading is an evaluation technique used by professional fact-checkers to determine the trustworthiness of online information. Watch the video to learn more about this technique.

Credit: Stanford History Education Group
Run Time: 3:47

Evaluating Your Sources: Publisher

Book and Journal publishers
What type of press are they: Academic? Commercial? Professional/Scholarly Organization? Vanity?

 

  • ​​Is there a peer-review process for accepting items for publication?
  • Look for the "Refereed" refereed symbol in Ulrich's Periodicals Directory Williams only resource
  • Look for author guidelines on the publisher's website; is the review process explained?

Find out more about a publisher: its market, audience, history, reputation

  • Writer's Market Call # Sawyer Reference PN161 .W8
  • Publisher's web site: how do they decide what to publish?
  • Ulrich's Periodicals Directory Williams only resource (look for reviews)
  • Left Guide Call # Sawyer Reference HS2321 .L44
  • Right Guide Call # Sawyer Reference HS2321 .R54

Evaluating Organizations